Pokemon Hacks/games?

[Viewier]

23 minutes ago, ZeroFives said:

 

That's fair. Again. You can stop the project for any reason you like. :3

Though I did probably go too far with requesting that others not continue it.

But I didn't want the same thing to happen a third time.

Moderators do have the power to destroy threads if they want.

[ZeroFives]

2 hours ago, Viewier said:

Though I did probably go too far with requesting that others not continue it.

But I didn't want the same thing to happen a third time.

Moderators do have the power to destroy threads if they want.

 

True. Unfortunate but true.

[Dwellernumber765]

7 hours ago, ZeroFives said:

This makes Zero sense to me once so ever. I mean. Do they have Game Freak's permission to edit the sprites into Mormon in the first place? What about Nintendo's permission? Did they give the okay for their IP to be used to make Moemon?

For someone who makes mods. To turn around and say no one is allowed to make a mod of their work. Just sounds ridiculous to me. I've seen this so much. "Here is a Mod I made without permission. Now. Don't you fucking dare to make a mod of it!" Is one of the stupidest arguments. They can say they don't want Edits to be done of their edits. Sure. But they do not. Under any circumstance. Have the moral high ground.

Mind you. I. Personally. Have Zero interest in Moemon. And Zero interest in a nude mod for it. But this just sounds like someone is abusing their mod powers to get rid of a project they do not like. Since, if it did break the rules. They would have just deleted the thread themselves. Having you delete it for them is strange. Like they wanted it gone, but knew they'd get in trouble if they removed it.

Also. Don't you already make nude edits without the permission of the owners of Pokemon's IPs? Do you really think Nintendo, Game Freak, or their Devs. Are okay with nude edits? Nintendo's official's stance on modding is that it should be 100% illegal to ever mod any game for any reason. Period.

In the end. It's your choice to end the project if you want too. You don't even need a reason to do so. I simply do not agree with the Moemon team's actions on this. It's just ridiculous.

At the end of the day, I still used their sprites without asking them. We're directly drawing over their own work, even if it's not their permission with the IP, they still have their own rights over their art. 
I'm personally not very offended by this, I knew it was going to happened eventually. I respect their decisions to protect their artists work because I'm a big fan of it.
Though the only thing I'm really curious about is why did no one contacted me to removed it. Viewer isn't really the one that's managing it as much as me but it could even be that they did and I was just incredibly inactive here recently so it moved onto Viewer
Either way, I'm not gonna try to continue to push the project further. I'll just leave the version I still have a hold off on my link and maybe shift to working for the Nude Project team more.

[Zorai]

10 hours ago, ZeroFives said:

This makes Zero sense to me once so ever. I mean. Do they have Game Freak's permission to edit the sprites into Mormon in the first place? What about Nintendo's permission? Did they give the okay for their IP to be used to make Moemon?

For someone who makes mods. To turn around and say no one is allowed to make a mod of their work. Just sounds ridiculous to me. I've seen this so much. "Here is a Mod I made without permission. Now. Don't you fucking dare to make a mod of it!" Is one of the stupidest arguments. They can say they don't want Edits to be done of their edits. Sure. But they do not. Under any circumstance. Have the moral high ground.

Mind you. I. Personally. Have Zero interest in Moemon. And Zero interest in a nude mod for it. But this just sounds like someone is abusing their mod powers to get rid of a project they do not like. Since, if it did break the rules. They would have just deleted the thread themselves. Having you delete it for them is strange. Like they wanted it gone, but knew they'd get in trouble if they removed it.

Also. Don't you already make nude edits without the permission of the owners of Pokemon's IPs? Do you really think Nintendo, Game Freak, or their Devs. Are okay with nude edits? Nintendo's official's stance on modding is that it should be 100% illegal to ever mod any game for any reason. Period.

In the end. It's your choice to end the project if you want too. You don't even need a reason to do so. I simply do not agree with the Moemon team's actions on this. It's just ridiculous.

 

Its more so to do with respecting what the original devs wanted, and mainly not using the work they've made. But otherwise, I do agree with you on this for the most part. While they don't want their work used, technically speaking, nothing is stopping someone from making their own Moemon nude mod with their own sprites and such. Since all they own is the sprites they made. Not the IP or the idea, nor the concept of making the pokemon half anthro humanoids.

 

7 hours ago, Viewier said:

Though I did probably go too far with requesting that others not continue it.

But I didn't want the same thing to happen a third time.

Moderators do have the power to destroy threads if they want.

 

1 hour ago, Dwellernumber765 said:

At the end of the day, I still used their sprites without asking them. We're directly drawing over their own work, even if it's not their permission with the IP, they still have their own rights over their art. 
I'm personally not very offended by this, I knew it was going to happened eventually. I respect their decisions to protect their artists work because I'm a big fan of it.
Though the only thing I'm really curious about is why did no one contacted me to removed it. Viewer isn't really the one that's managing it as much as me but it could even be that they did and I was just incredibly inactive here recently so it moved onto Viewer
Either way, I'm not gonna try to continue to push the project further. I'll just leave the version I still have a hold off on my link and maybe shift to working for the Nude Project team more.

 

To be fair, as long as the sprites are original and not the same ones used in Moemon, a mod can still be made. As I said above, its mainly the sprites and art that they requested to not be used as far as I'm aware. Which is valid. But they do not own the concept of half anthro humanoids. If that's all Moemon is, then one can still make a nude mod as long as the sprites and artwork is original and different, and not a direct copy. They have the right to ask others not to use their work, but they don't have the right to demand that no one makes anything at all.

[Viewier]

7 hours ago, Zorai said:

 

Its more so to do with respecting what the original devs wanted, and mainly not using the work they've made. But otherwise, I do agree with you on this for the most part. While they don't want their work used, technically speaking, nothing is stopping someone from making their own Moemon nude mod with their own sprites and such. Since all they own is the sprites they made. Not the IP or the idea, nor the concept of making the pokemon half anthro humanoids.

 

 

 

To be fair, as long as the sprites are original and not the same ones used in Moemon, a mod can still be made. As I said above, its mainly the sprites and art that they requested to not be used as far as I'm aware. Which is valid. But they do not own the concept of half anthro humanoids. If that's all Moemon is, then one can still make a nude mod as long as the sprites and artwork is original and different, and not a direct copy. They have the right to ask others not to use their work, but they don't have the right to demand that no one makes anything at all.

Oh true!

I think that they weren't saying that absolutely no mod where the pokemon are naked people could be made. They just didn't want their sprites to be edited.