What is the Current "best" Defeat Mod?

[Laoren]

Basicly title. Ive been using Practical Defeat Reanimated but its not very reliable for starting creature animations, so i ask what is a good alternativ? Mainly looking for the option to have my Character be Raped by NPC and Creatures and sold into slavery.

[Telis5678]

I mean, Naked Defeat is the most popular for a reason, but the Baka version has some synergy when it comes to other mods from the author, so there's that.

[outcast]

Depends what exactly you are looking for, I use Defeat Updated by Bane Master, in my experience it is the most stable and bug free Defeat mod which is a priority for me. However, I disable NPC vs NPC scenes, otherwise civil war battles turn into huge orgy and that is definitely not my cup of tea. 

 

[Omnishade]

SL Defeat is the most immersive and reliable imo. It's the defeat mod that "makes the most sense" for a defeated by bandits and abused scenario. Naked Defeat is also an interesting mod if you want a lot of extra features, such as whipping, and just want kink over immersion.

 

Practical Defeat lacked the settings I would like for a defeat mod when I tried it, and didn't really bring anything new to table, but it might have had some updates since then.

[Laoren]

13 hours ago, Omnishade said:

Practical Defeat lacked the settings I would like for a defeat mod when I tried it, and didn't really bring anything new to table, but it might have had some updates since then.

I really liked the struggleing mini game it had 

 

21 hours ago, outcast said:

Depends what exactly you are looking for, I use Defeat Updated by Bane Master, in my experience it is the most stable and bug free Defeat mod which is a priority for me. However, I disable NPC vs NPC scenes, otherwise civil war battles turn into huge orgy and that is definitely not my cup of tea. 

 
Been test running this one now and it works pretty good so far.

[Omnishade]

1 hour ago, Laoren said:

I really liked the struggleing mini game it had 

 

 
Been test running this one now and it works pretty good so far.

 

Since we're talking about it now, does it have:

A. An option to prevent the same aggressor from taking part in a scene twice? In defeat that's insatiable aggressors disabled.
B. The chance for a group animation?

C. Options for post-defeat?

[Laoren]

9 hours ago, Omnishade said:

 

Since we're talking about it now, does it have:

A. An option to prevent the same aggressor from taking part in a scene twice? In defeat that's insatiable aggressors disabled.
B. The chance for a group animation?

C. Options for post-defeat?

A. Not sure about that one
B. Ive seen Group animations happen
C. I got Simple Slavery happen after the assault

[Ralin Drakus]

On 3/8/2026 at 11:36 AM, outcast said:

Depends what exactly you are looking for, I use Defeat Updated by Bane Master, in my experience it is the most stable and bug free Defeat mod which is a priority for me. However, I disable NPC vs NPC scenes, otherwise civil war battles turn into huge orgy and that is definitely not my cup of tea. 

The old Defeat had a percentage bar you could adjust for the likelihood of an assault happening - Does the updated version not have that?

 

Also looking for suggestions to the best modern Defeat mod out there. Loved the old Defeat because unlike most of the newer versions I wanna turn off assault on the player; I'm the perv not just the NPCs lol. The OG mod had every possible fine tuning and preference option one could hope for, but as has been mentioned it was slow and was getting buggy the last time I played it.