Jump to content

I need your opinion guys !


Pharazith

935 views

I need your opinion !  

16 members have voted

  1. 1. Wich version do you prefer ?

    • v1.
      4
    • v2.
      2
    • v3.
      10
    • None, you're not experienced enough to make a video game.
      0

This poll is closed to new votes

Edit: Seems like we are going for version 3. Thank you all for your comments and votes, that's very nice of you ! I'll let the poll open for one more week just in case but I doubt the result will drastically change until then.

 

Hi guys, long time no see, sorry about that...

The reason why I've been so silent lately is because I'm working on a visual novel. This is what I want to talk to you about. Right now I'm still trying to find wich style would fit the best to the game, and I'd like to have your opinion because, well, I'm making this game for you too so your opinion matters.

 

Please share as much as possible as the more feedbacks I get the more relevant the results will be.

 

Pharazith 

Test.jpg

10 Comments


Recommended Comments

The classical design and the clear and strong contours of no.1 gives the girl the most distinctive look. 2 is looking somewhat blurry, 3 I don't get a clear vibe. Could be working girl as well as some college confident girl... or not. Hard to say.

 

All in all, you could do most settings with no. 1; 3 seems limited in this category.

 

But it all depends what your work is about. 3 is the most detailed look, so if you want go for eye candy and sexyness, 3 is the case, while 1 leaves more options for plot developement.

Hope this helps - and good luck.

Link to comment
31 minutes ago, Swiftstep said:

The classical design and the clear and strong contours of no.1 gives the girl the most distinctive look. 2 is looking somewhat blurry, 3 I don't get a clear vibe. Could be working girl as well as some college confident girl... or not. Hard to say.

 

All in all, you could do most settings with no. 1; 3 seems limited in this category.

 

But it all depends what your work is about. 3 is the most detailed look, so if you want go for eye candy and sexyness, 3 is the case, while 1 leaves more options for plot developement.

Hope this helps - and good luck.

Thanks, it does help ! I agree I prefer 1 & 2 too.

The poll is mostly about the line style. I'll make multiple poses and faces for every character to fit their personality, so don't worry about that. 

 

Thank you very much for taking the time to write this feedback and for the wishes ! 

Link to comment

Personally, I prefer version 3 by far. Clothes and style are a matter of tastes, but while the °1 has interesting features,°3 looks far more defined in terms of details.It's like if it was a 720P version, while the others are 360, with°2 being the most blurred of the three. The collarbones, moles and eyebrowns are a good example of that definition loss. ?

 

And as Swiftstep said, good luck with your game. Smiley_jap_HFR.gif

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Resdayn said:

1. look more unique while the 2 just blurry and 3. kinda feels generic.

Thank you very much for the feedbacks ! 1 is in deed the most personnal style, I really appreciate the fact you find it unique ! 3 is voluntarily generic as I wanted a version more apprehendable for those who does not really care about art.

 

Thanks for showing interest for my work once more !

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Tirloque said:

Personally, I prefer version 3 by far. Clothes and style are a matter of tastes, but while the °1 has interesting features,°3 looks far more defined in terms of details.It's like if it was a 720P version, while the others are 360, with°2 being the most blurred of the three. The collarbones, moles and eyebrowns are a good example of that definition loss. ?

 

And as Swiftstep said, good luck with your game. Smiley_jap_HFR.gif

Thank you for the feedbacks and the wishes ! Hehe considering our previous discussions, I'm not surprised you're not particularly fond of the blurry versions ; )

Link to comment
13 minutes ago, Agent Tex said:

3

Thank you very much for taking the time to give me your opinion that means a lot to me !

Link to comment
25 minutes ago, Pharazith said:

Thank you very much for the feedbacks ! 1 is in deed the most personnal style, I really appreciate the fact you find it unique ! 3 is voluntarily generic as I wanted a version more apprehendable for those who does not really care about art.

 

Thanks for showing interest for my work once more !

I always value personal styles more, its shines much better and showcasing your artistic side ?

 

But for a visual novel, I have to agree with the others, 3 seems the most fitting due being generic.

 

You can't truly unleash your style and creativity when you need making something everyone should like. ?

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Resdayn said:

I always value personal styles more, its shines much better and showcasing your artistic side ?

 

But for a visual novel, I have to agree with the others, 3 seems the most fitting due being generic.

 

You can't truly unleash your style and creativity when you need making something everyone should like. ?

Yes that's what I thought too. Thank you very much for the great compliment and the advice, I really like how you think.

Link to comment
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. For more information, see our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use