Weirdly detailed request for game suggestions

[MadGenuis]

Okay, so, I don’t know how fruitful this request will end up being or whether it is a good - or decent, even - idea to put it forth for suggestions, but I’ve thought about it for a long time now and decided that the worst thing that can happen is for people to learn the particular quirks of this particular persona of mine without me getting anything out of it. And really, anyone reading my stories (when they were still publically available) would already know some of them.
To stop myself from rambling on along that train of thought, onwards: I am posting now in hopes of receiving suggestions on hentai games to try. This particular request is nothing new, as I’ve seen several other people asking for suggestions here just in my time on the site, but... to speak in metaphors, I would like to use the search engine of the combined archive of perversions available here with more specific parameters.
 
More simply put, I will list a few hentai games that I’ve tried (and whether I liked or disliked them, with spoilers specifying my thoughts on them) (I suppose this list also can work as suggestions for others looking for such games, if they want to try any of them) and a number of preferences I have when it comes to this particular genre (likewise with spoilers containing my thoughts, but with a code by each “preference title”; these codes will be +++: needs to be there, ++: would love to be there, +: would like to be there, -: would prefer as being avoidable in the game (as in, not mandatory), --: would hate to be forced through it and ---: won’t accept being forced through).
You’re still with me? Nice. I’m not sharing all of this admittedly extremely private information about me for fun, of course; I’m merely hoping that allowing you a rather intimate familiarity with my likes and dislikes might result in the best hentai game for me.
 
With the introductions out of the way, let us commence with the listing of hentai games:
 
Artificial Girl 3 - Like

Might as well start with the hentai game I’ve been going back to most frequently, though never for long before moving on again. I only sort of like this game, in the sense that I specifically like the perverse content of it. The female characters can look nice (or really weird; breast shape and sizes in this game can put me off a bit, if done wrong), they can display some degree of individuality and personality, and you can assign them the trait to be blood relatives. Hell yes.
The game requires a little bit of work getting the girls to like you - just enough that you feel like the girl isn’t just immediately agreeing to sleep with you because it’s a hentai game - and it’s pretty much smooth sailing from there, which is both a strong point and weakness. If you just have an itch to scratch right quick, this game serves extraordinarily well (at least it does for me), but it gets a bit boring in the long run, especially since I don’t really want to earn all the traits that can be earned in game, like “pervert” (or whatever it is called) and “likes anal”.
A nice little game, but ultimately nothing special.

 
Artificial Academy 2 - Meh

I don’t really know what to think of this game. The characters are a bit on the “meh” side, neither good looking nor ugly, and more cute than sexy (which is not necessarily a bad thing; patting certain girls head in this game can be inexplicably arousing). They have a hint of personality, though nowhere near as much as in Artificial Girl 3, can act on their own (and start scenes on their own, though your ability to witness those scenes can be very limited). The strongest advantage this has over AG3 is the fact that you can play as a girl and have lesbian relationships.
You basically have a choice with this game: either you play it for the sex (which is really the point; there is little to no reason to play it otherwise) or you play it for one of the shallowest school-simulation games I’ve ever even heard of, trying to be popular, to do well, and to get that special someone/those special someones to like you enough for you to be an item/items. And while the school-simulation is weak, the sex is just as weak. Enter sex-scene; choose foreplay; choose next stage, be that sex or more foreplay, repeat until sex; choose how to climax; repeat if so desired. That’s it.
It’s a shallow game with very little to offer, aside from smirking at an adorable anime-ish girl when you pat her head, or if you want to watch monotonous, mostly non-interactive sex between such characters. It earns a point for it being possible for girls to get pregnant, but loses that point by such pregnancy being “game over” for (at least) that girl. So yeah, meh indeed.

 
RapeLay - Conditional like or dislike

As will be mentioned when I get to my preferences, I don’t like rape, I don’t like domination and I don’t like humiliation, so starting off I dislike this game. “But why would you even try a game with the word ‘rape’ in the title if your preferences are like that, MadGenuis?” I’m glad you asked. Because in the end-game, after the characters are “broken” (which I made them be from the start by cheating), your character has a seemingly consensual sexual relationship with a mother and her two daughters, and can have threesomes and foursomes with them. The girls/women look pretty okay, you can pretty much make any combination of the three (so mother/daughter or sister/sister) have sex with each other, and the youngest daughter - related guilt aside - is stupidly cute.
Unfortunately, breaking the girls - humiliating, dominating and generally mistreating them, all while they are begging for mercy - is most of the game, which means that I mostly detest it. The end-game, while nice, no longer has any goals or any progression, the sex becomes almost non-interactive - merely sprinkled with a tiny bit of unsatisfactory interaction - and while it’s often hot, it quickly becomes monotonous. I would really like to never think of this game again, but the fact that it features incest and has the possibility of pregnancy pretty much secures it a place in my memories, if not on my hard-drive.
Oh yeah, the pregnancy. Unless you get the girl to get an abortion, the girls kill you. Game over. And if you have sex with the older daughter certain ways before she is “broken”, she might kill you too. With scissors. Game over. So... nah.

 
Musumakeup - Yeeeaahhhh no. Could have been.

So you’re an alchemist who finds a baby, and raise her pretty much all the way until she is a young adult. Loads of story - and I mean a ton of it! - and a lot of investment goes into this game. Some humor, mainly the stupid kind, and so much emotional investment that I actually just sat there smiling as dialogue passed by. You actually get invested (I overuse that word now...) in the daughter because there is so much exposition, such a long story, and such a human touch to her. I sat there for hours going through the game, and then... well-written dialogue was replaced with one of the worst machine-translations I’ve ever seen. And that continued through most of the game. It’s a ridiculously long story, and most of it is very poorly translated, which kills my enjoyment of it completely. I actually broke my old mouse clicking through the badly translated scenes as fast as possible, and it still took me forever to get through it all. So. Much. Story. Then suddenly (or maybe it would be less sudden if you actually tried to piece together some semblance of meaning from the nonsense text at the bottom of the screen) there’s a sex scene with your daughter, then another one, and maybe another one? Not even sure. The end. And I sit back thinking “what the hell did I waste the last three hours of my life on?”
This game... no. Maybe if it had been properly translated to English all the way through, but even then it fails completely as a hentai game. Yeah, you have sex with your adopted daughter, but... the sex is bad (AA2 style, referring earlier on the list), and it’s kind of just there. Seriously weird game. Not even a real game, to be honest; more like a slightly interactive visual novel.

 
Monster Girl - I can’t believe that I like this game
 

The gameplay is kind of okay in this game, and a lot of the characters are genuinely attractive, but mostly it’s really just a visual novel in disguise. Sure, there are (very many) battles which can technically be lost with some different outcomes in which the main character (male) gets raped and killed or enslaved, and you can make the “wrong” choice, which results in a prompt game over (typically after a rape-scene), but there’s really only ever one way to go, one thing to do.
So the gameplay is subpar at best, and absent most of the time, and about 99% of the sexual content of the game only occurs if you lose battles, which means that your character gets raped and enslaved or killed. The story is quite honestly downright kind of stupid at worst and cliché at best, and even the sexual content that I would allow myself to enjoy is rather rare and not that interesting.
Why, then, do I like this game? Why in the world was I invested in that stupid, cliché story, despite the fact that you could tell from a mile away what would happen every time? I genuinely don’t know, but the fact remains that when I completed the third and final chapter of this game and watched the credits roll by, my heart felt heavy with loss; a sensation that is familiar to me, but only in relation to the best of stories, be those written down or featured in games. (Mass Effect would probably have made me feel this way, had I not been thoroughly enraged at it for its ending sucking ass. Speaking of Mass Effect: Tali all the way.)
I honestly don’t know what to say about this game, in conclusion. I dislike every aspect of it, but like the game in its entirety.

 
Sexy Beach - Dislike

“Which one?” All of them. Yes, some of the girls are hot. You spend an ungodly amount of time gaining their affection (which is nice at first, but gets repetitive really quickly), and then you get to have sex with that girl... which is nice at first, but gets repetitive really quickly. Seeing a pattern? No amount of breast and butt physics and adorable (but ultimately stupid) behavior can help me get over what an absolute chore these games are. “Oh look! She’s chasing a butterfly!” Yeah, that’s cute and sexy exactly once. “Let me apply some lotion here...” Yeah, that’s hot at first, but not the tenth, or twentieth, or umpteenth time. Basically, it’s boring and repetitive, even if the girls are among the best looking, if at times unfavorably proportioned in my opinion.
And let’s not even talk about Premium Resort, before you mention it. I tried that game exactly once, saw how poorly it performed, saw my character’s running animation, and uninstalled. No. Just... no. These games are evidence that graphics and bouncing girl-assets are not everything.

 
Nekopara - What am I doing with my life?

I... I don’t know what I was thinking. I don’t know what I was expecting. I have no idea how many hours of mundane story and disposition I had to sit through on this one, to be rewarded with a few nude pictures and three or four sex scenes. Cat-girls are sexy and all, especially loli cat-girls, but seriously... I... uh...
And I kept hoping that the whole incest-angle would play out a bit more, with the sister actually getting it on with your character, but nope. That part of the story is really just a tease all the way through.
The sex scenes are nice, don’t get me wrong, but... why am I even wasting my time with visual novels? I... they... I don’t even know anymore.

 
Violated Heroine - Like... mostly

Okay, so most of the sex scenes are locked behind “you have to lose to this enemy to get this”, which sucks, but... this game. I like it. Sex-scenes are often very arousing, the main character is quite attractive, and with a personality determined by your actions, it features pregnancy, bestiality, incest and pregnancy resulting from bestiality and incest. Oh yes. The story is kind of okay, though often downright absent, but the gameplay is strangely addicting.
Go out, kill these things, get reward. Be a waitress, get reward. Babysit, get reward. Kill stuff. Kill harder stuff. Kill more stuff! Fight your way through harder and harder dungeons, fight this boss, fail and fail until you succeed, next dungeon next boss, onwards, fight, do a job, rewards aplenty, story, story, explore, fight, aaaaaand...
Japanese symbols? And that is why the game isn’t the best one ever, even beside the fact that you have to lose to experience a lot of the content. It’s not finished. You want to try going south from the first town? You get a very nice little bit of dialogue from a house with some brother/sister incest, and then the game tells you that the area will have more in it later. Explore far enough, or advance far enough in the story, and everything starts being either Japanese or machine translation of Japanese.
Still, it’s an amazing hentai game, one of the better ones for sure.

 
RyonaRPG - Undecided

Why undecided? Because the game is hard, and has surprisingly little sexual content for a hentai game... so little, in fact, that I barely think I’ve encountered any of it (aside from the characters inexplicably screaming in ecstasy when they’re defeated. I sort of like the gameplay, though, and I like the promise the sprites in the game content folder has. I just wish I got to see some of it in-game...

 
Corruption of Champions - Like

If you like text-based erotica, like I do, do not play this game. Really. It will take up way too much of your time. But seriously, your character can be changed in almost every way imaginable, pregnancy is heavily featured, as is lactation and frankly too many fetishes to recount, and it’s just generally a good time. Lots of content, too. My main complaint about the game is that most of the incest-scenes (which are few already) require a high corruption of your character, which also makes the character dislikable overall, in my opinion. I’ve tried playing as pure and corrupted, and I’ll play as pure every time, despite my missing out on the incest.

 
Trials of Tainted Space - Like

Basically like Corruption of Champions, just science-fiction instead of fantasy, and with much more emphasis on story than impregnating everything with a womb, or getting impregnated by everything with sperm... or eggs... or whatever, really. It’s okay, but I ultimately like CoC better.

 
I guess those are all the hentai games I remember having played. Now, though, a few honorable mentions:
 
Skyrim with SexLab - Like

Great game, good mods, good times. I liked Skyrim from the start, mods made it better, and SexLab made it awesome. Yeah.

 
Oblivion with Lovers with PK - Like

Pretty much the same story as with Skyrim. Good times were had.

 
Fallout New Vegas with Sexout - Cautious like

Don’t get me wrong, the mods for Fallout New Vegas are great, and I mostly enjoy the game, but... New Vegas is just kind of too easy. And too short. I never really realized it until I one day was wandering around the Mohave looking for something new to do, and realized there was nothing left. That never happened to me in Fallout 3, or in Oblivion, or Skyrim. It’s simply too small.

 
The Sims 3 with Nraas Woohooer - LIKE!

Now, I basically have very limited interest in The Sims-games... unless I play them. I don’t like them particularly, but if someone gets me to play it, I’ll be damned if I’m not going to sit there for hours getting money to build a better house, always bigger and better, and max that skill and that skill, get all the stuff, collect one of every type of Sim... I don’t even like the damn game, but it’s been a major time-sink nevertheless.
And then I found Nraas. All those rules and limitations the game had about what you aren’t allowed to do? Out the window. Start a family with a pair of twin sisters (because I SAID they are twins, that’s why!), play as normal... only, those sisters now fall in love. Get married. Have children, which are obviously daughters because I force-feed the mother watermelon. Have those daughters have daughters with each other or with their parents, or both. Create the most fucked-up family tree ever seen outside medieval royalty.
...There is something seriously wrong with me.

 
With that out of the way, time to have a go at my preferences... ugh. Honesty about this kind of stuff feels... weird.
 
Vaginal intercourse +++

Does this really need an explanation? It’s sex, and the best kind in my opinion.

 
Cunnilingus and vaginal fingering ++

I don’t think this particular urge of mine is strange, or unusual, but I prioritize the pleasure of my partner (and thus the female participant) over my own. And if it’s two girls doing it with one another... well, it’s about fifty times hotter.

 
Anal sex -

This is probably where my preferences start deviating from the norm. I don’t like anal sex. It doesn’t kill me to have to sit through it, but I don’t enjoy it either. The same goes for anal fingering, though I don’t dislike it as much.

 
Rimjobs --

Noooooo... No. No! No. Nope. Ugh.

 
Watersports and scat ---

I will find you, and I will punch you in the face.

 
Snuff ---

Let’s get these out of the way immediately.

 
Bondage and domination -

Not really my thing.

 
Humiliation and rape --

Actually disgust me.

 
Gore --

Disgusting.

 
Gay (male homosexuality) ---

No.

 
Unrealistically huge proportions -

As in very large breasts, butts and penises. I don’t like those.

 
Vaginal creampie +++

This needs to be there, simple as that, otherwise I’m just not interested.

 
Impregnation and pregnancy ++

I really like this, especially if combined with incest or bestiality.

 
Birth +

Same as impregnation and pregnancy, I just don’t like it as much. I like it ten times as much if the progeny stays around, and infinitely more if you can then have naughty fun times with said progeny.

 
Lactation ++

It’s probably pretty weird to find that sexy.

 
Incest ++

I don’t know why, and frankly I don’t want to try to figure out why. All I know is that this, maybe tied with impregnation, is my greatest fetish. Sister/sister and brother/sister incest are the best, father/daughter comes in second, mother/daughter third and mother/son last.

 
Bestiality +

Kind of nice, if done correctly. Can be disgusting, though. So yeah.

 
Loli ++

Specifically, the features I relate to this attribute is generally petite/slender proportions and a naïve, innocent and generally good-natured personality.

 
Lesbian sex ++

Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

 
Futanari (woman with penis) +

It’s actually a bit of a mess, this one, since it’s a bit conditional. If it is a futanari using her penis on a girl, then I’m all for it. Pairing a futanari with a male, however, and I start feeling a little worse about it, but probably mostly neutrally bad rather than downright disliking it. The reason it has a less positive priority than lesbian sex is basically that I fundamentally feel a sexual dislike towards penises in general, and that the main advantage a futanari has over a regular woman is the ability to creampie and impregnate other women - or themselves. Oh god...
One of my greatest regrets about Corruption of Champions is the fact that there is a scene in there in which a futa character inserts their own penis into their own vagina and creampies themselves, but there is no chance of pregnancy from the encounter. I sooo wish that could happen.

 
Cum-inflation +

Unrealistic though it may be, it’s still hot.

 
Unbirthing ++/---, Vore +/---

Basically, the reason these two have two different grades that are very far apart is because my opinion of them depends on the outcome. If the person being swallowed/unbirthed dies, or if the person doing the swallowing/unbirthing dies, I won’t have anything to do with it. If they stay alive (one way or another), however, I’m all for it. That stuff is neat.

 
Sexual preferences aside, I also have some particular gaming-related preferences, which I will just summarize quickly:

I don’t like to have to lose. I don’t really mind losing as long as I feel that I was defeated fairly (I’m a SoulBorne player), and I like a challenge, but you’ll never ever see me lose on purpose. Consequently, you can probably discard any game that requires the player to lose to experience the sexual content, because I’m a fairly quick learner and unlikely to lose a lot.
As said before, I like a challenge. In other words, I like to feel as though I’ve earned my win. This goes for hentai games as well: simply going up to another character and saying “Hi, do you want to have sex?” should not automatically result in sex. I’d prefer that there was progression before getting to that point.
I like there to be a premise. Simply “you are in a house” doesn’t really do a lot, does it? Why are they there? Where did they come from? What house is it? So many questions...
I don’t know if you noticed this trait in my description of some of the hentai games earlier, but I don’t like bad English in games. I can understand if a person has bad English, and I won’t blame them or hold it against them. Heck, English is not my native language either, I can even relate with them. But in a game, similar to in literature, you have every opportunity to correct your mistakes, and that makes mistakes intolerable.
And finally, I dislike endings. Like, a lot. You cannot begin to comprehend how much I loathe endings. So I would definitely prefer if there at least was an option to simply keep playing forever (I’m not going to, probably, but I like the option).

 
So there you have it. That... was a seriously lot of crap I just dumped on you guys. I’m sorry, I really am. But anyone who survived reading through this, or even just skimming it without reading the spoilers, please feel free to suggest any hentai game you think I would enjoy from the abundant information I’ve supplied here.
Thank you in advance.

[Devious Dingbat]

No responses? Probably a tl;dr situation.

 

OK, so after reading everything here, this is pretty much what you want.

 

A hentai game, preferably a game with no ending, featuring straight/lesbian sex (funtari included), lolis, incest and impregnation. Text based games are welcome, VN are not.

If done right, bestiality and vore are also welcome, although it has to be consensual. Also lose to see hentai is a big nono.

 

A quick question, how do you feel about tentacles?

 

After some research, you might like Internal Interrogation.

 

It's a small, short $5 game, featuring futa on female. Whilst I haven't played it, there is actual game play involved, so it's more than just a VN.

 

Reasons it might appeal: Futa, lesbian and not a VN. Vaginal intercourse and probably cream pie. 100% English. The sex is integral to the plot, so you don't have to lose to see it.

Reasons it might not: I'm not sure quite how consensual it is. You don't have to work to get to the sex, there is an ending, the women are in prison so there's technically bondage, although minor.

Game link: http://hentaiwriter.tumblr.com/post/145329297564/hey-the-second-game-for-the-new-small-games

 

It seems like the hentai community is working against you in a lot of ways. There's plenty of content you'd like but then it's all rape, VN or just a simple press a for sex kinda game. 

[MadGenuis]

Ha, this sits around for almost half a year without anyone replying to it, only for it to get a reply on the very same day I posted a similar topic, only made less extensive and more easily readable, in the adult games section? Really, what are the odds?

But thanks for the suggestion! In regards to your question, I suppose I'm fairly ambivalent in regards to tentacles? I don't really like or dislike them, so their inclusion neither bothers nor pleases me.

[ReMeDy]

For me personally, I found the different font choice you went with a bit too small to read, and you did indeed ramble a lot early on, lol. Don't be intimidated about your sexual fantasies here. Believe me, it can't be nearly as fucked up as some of the other things I've read here from others!

 

Beyond that, it's hard to recommend games because truth be told, unless you know Japanese, you're basically stuck with obscure RPG Maker and text Javascript games. Although some Japanese games you don't need to know Japanese, like Ryona type stuff.

[Devious Dingbat]

Another game you might want to check out is Aylia's Story. An RPG maker game early in development. Written in English so no crappy translations, not only sexual encounters when you lose and a lot of promise. It features a slow corruption mechanic, like Violated Heroine and Virgin Island (Which might also be worth a look, just the translation is incomplete. If you thought Violated Heroine was bad stay far away from this) so the more erotic situations happen the more depraved the main character gets. The biggest feature that interests me at least, is the rival system. You can "Screw" over other female rivals, leading to them having a much harder time in general.

 

Right now there isn't much content but it is completely free, so defiantly worth a look.

 

Game link:http://www.ulmf.org/bbs/showthread.php?t=26632

[Snoopy911]

About the SIms you found Nraas but you didn't mention this one

http://www.loverslab.com/topic/43249-sims3wip-kinkyworld-v028-updated-15-sep-2016/

 

[RoKFenris]

I get the feeling you would like Vitamin Plus. Free, in English, created with RPG Maker (though a good quality one), featuring a good amount of incest and bestiality. I've... kinda liked the part I played, except that bestiality is a huge turn off for me, so when that started in earnest I stopped playing.

[MadGenuis]

Started writing a longer post for this thread, was almost done, switched to a different tab for a second, came back, hit backspace before clicking back into the reply-box... Yeah. Super.

 

I guess I will go with a shorter version of the post I originally wrote: I'll have a look at those games at some point, and I have actually found and tried KinkyWorld in the half year that has passed since posting this thread.

KinkyWorld seems nice, with pretty okay animations and options that mostly let it suit my preferences, but it seems as though it does affect performance somewhat, increasing the stutter (the game freezing every now and then for varying lengths of time while it figures out what to do with itself) that was already somewhat frustrating in it. The main reason that I did/do not play it more than I have/am, however, is mostly due to how long it takes to load... Not counting starting the game, just loading a save can take 15-20 minutes for me, if not longer, which is a massive hurdle to be willing to get past. I mean, I have to be pretty sure that I want to and am going to play the game for quite a while before it's even worth trying to load on in.

[Snoopy911]

2:30 Loading time for me with a one year old pc and gigabytes of cc using save cleaner and removing cache files. About stutter it's different for me in different towns. Appaloosa Plains is close to impossible. Playing in Twinbrooks now and there is only a freeze once a day when nraas cleaning dows it's thing for about 3 seconds.

[Guest]

Interesting, I'm looking for pretty much the same things in a game, let me know if you find something you really like. Although one thing I will say is that I do prefer the games to have animations for sex scenes. I tried VH and I kinda like the game, but I wish it had better scenes, instead of the same generic ones every time of tits being squeezed or a close up of a vagina with a detached penis penetrating it.

[Devious Dingbat]

Interesting, I'm looking for pretty much the same things in a game, let me know if you find something you really like. Although one thing I will say is that I do prefer the games to have animations for sex scenes. I tried VH and I kinda like the game, but I wish it had better scenes, instead of the same generic ones every time of tits being squeezed or a close up of a vagina with a detached penis penetrating it.

Agreed. Violated Heroine is great for all the secrets, game play, variety, corruption mechanic ect but the one area it falls down in is defiantly the animations. I can deal with it though so it's OK for me.

[Guest]

My favorite was just Skyrim with lots of various sexlab mods installed, because I could make it more or less into exactly what I wanted. But now I can't really play that as I had more or less broken my game and so I re-installed it. Now it just feels like to much work to completely remod it, as I had 100+ mods installed.

[Devious Dingbat]

I know that feeling, I "Down"graded to Windows 7 from 10 over the weekend. Not only did I lose every file when something went wrong, but I had to download new drivers ect. I've only just downloaded Skyrim again and I have no idea when I'll care enough to download my mods again.

 

The worst part by far though, is the config that you need to do on every new game.